Hazrat Abdullah Bin Abbas (RA) aur Tafseer Ibn-e-Abbas ka Muqam

Discussion in 'Islam' started by Midtown, Apr 15, 2008.

  1. Midtown

    Midtown New Member

    Aslam-o-Alikum,
    Aik Bhai ne bari bey dardi say Tafseer Ibn-e-Abbas per tanqeed ki jo mujhe acha nahi laga.
    Unhain cahiye inn Ahadith ko Madday nazar rakh kar khamosh ho jain.


    Abdullah-bin-abbas-aur-tafs.gif
     
  2. Ghost Rider

    Ghost Rider New Member

    Midtown bhai baat sirf itne see hai jiss ko jiss ke sath pyar hota hai woh uss ki tareef sun kar khush ho jata hai humain Nabi Pak (sallalahualiwasalam) ke sahaba say pyar hai hum un ki taref sun kar khush hotay hein jinhain nai woh pareshan hote hein beharhal buhat acha article hai.
     
  3. asim10

    asim10 New Member

    yaar midtwon bahi kiuon ghalt ilzam lagatay hoo. rushed nay tafseer ibn abbas ke baat ke hay sydna ibn abbas kee nahin.plz yaar app ilzam lagatay waqat sahih baat kiya karain.
    plz app zara khud sochain kiya sydna ibn abbas nay kowee tafseer likhi bhee thee jo un kay naam say mansoob ke jaa aiy.yeh to aik sahabi per jhoot hay jo yaqeenan ghalt hay.
     
  4. aitbaar

    aitbaar New Member

    thnx dear
     
  5. rushed

    rushed New Member

    Asslamoalaikum 2 all muslims,

    MidTown sahib Hazrat Abdullah Ibn-e-Abbas R.A. ka jo moqam-o-mertaba hai ham aap se ziada maante hain. Unn ki tafseer ka moqam bhi sab jaante hain mager woh jo unn se sahih saabit ho.

    Hamara aitraaz Hazrat Ibn-e-Abbas ya unn ki ki hui tafseer jo unn se sahih saabit ho per nahin bal'k unn k naam per mash'hoor ker di gai kitaab tafseer Ibn-e-Abbas per hai. Yeh tafseer ki kitaab Ibn-e-Abbas R.A ne bian nahin ki bal'k unn ki taraf jhoote rawion ne mansoob ki hai. Jis ko main saabit ker chukka hoon. Aap bajae apni galat baat ko tasleem kerne k mujh per galat ilzaam laga rahe hai. Ager meri baat galat hai to usse dalael se sabit karen. Mahez jhoote ilzaam na lagaen.
    Allah aap ko hadayat de.
     
  6. Mass

    Mass New Member

    Jazakallah great sharing janab.
     
  7. mohammed jahangir

    mohammed jahangir New Member

    nice sharing midtown
     
  8. Midtown

    Midtown New Member

    Asim bhai aghar Hazrat Ibn-e-Abbas (RA) ne Tafseer nah likhi hoti tu maine jo Hadith Tafseer Ibn-e-Kaseer say pesh ki uss main Hazrat Ibn-e-Abbas (RA) ko buhat acha Muffasir kyon kaha gaya ?...
    Humare Ulama ne aisay hee unn ki Tafseer ka Tarjuma nahi kia aur Alhumdullilah humare aik Dars main lahore Tafseer Ibn-e-Abbas (RA) Arabic main bhi hai.

    rushed bhai aik taraf app kehte ho unhon ne likhi aik taraf kehte ho nahi likhi yeh unn ki taraf jhoot mansob kia gaya hai pehle app yeh batain app kia mantay hon Tafseer Ibn-e-Abbas hai ya nahi ?
     
  9. rushed

    rushed New Member

    Asslamoalaikum 2 all muslims,

    MidTown bhai iss ki wazahet pehle bhi ker chukka hoon k jo tafseer unn se sahih sanad se mile woh hamen qabool hai. Mager jis kitaab ka hawala aap dete hain jo k Tafseer Ibn-e-Abbas k naam se mojood hai woh Hazrat Ibn-e-Abbas ki taraf jhoot mansoob hai aur main iss baat ko sabit ker chukka hoon. Iss kitaab ka koi taluq Hazrat Ibn-e-Abbas R.A se nahin. Mahez unn ka naam istimaal kia gaya hai.
    Hazrat Ibn-e-Abbas R.A ke sahih tafseeri aqwal hadees aur tafseer ki kitabon main mojood hain. Allah samajhne ki tofeeq de, Aameen
     
  10. Midtown

    Midtown New Member

    rushed bhai app ne meri nazar main abhi tak kuch sabat nahi kiya.
    App ne jinn Books ka hawala diya pata nahi unn ka wajood bhi hai ya nahi.
    Beharhal baat sirf itne see hai ke Tafseer Ibn-e-Abbas meray pass mojod hai jiss ka Urdu main bhi tarjuma hoo chuka hai aghar yeh Maan gharat Book hoti tu humare itne baray Alim iss tafseer ka kabhi Urdu main tarjuma nah karty.
    Baqi rahi sabat karne ki baat tu yeh sirf app ki khush fehmi hai app ne abhi tak kuch bhi sabit nahi kia.
     
  11. Ghost Rider

    Ghost Rider New Member

    nice sharing Midtown bhai.
     
  12. desimunda

    desimunda New Member

    nice share
     
  13. pervaz

    pervaz New Member

    very nice sharing
     
  14. mohammed jahangir

    mohammed jahangir New Member

  15. Midtown

    Midtown New Member

    Thanks to All :)
     
  16. Gladiator89

    Gladiator89 New Member

    Great sharing Midtown bhai JazakAllah.
     
  17. kashmiri_munda

    kashmiri_munda New Member

    hhmm Nice and Informative ..
     
  18. Midtown

    Midtown New Member

    Sukriya Gladiator89 & kashmiri_munda bhai post passand karne ka.
     

Share This Page